Attention in Spanish and English Schedule (Madrid) L–J 09:00–14:00 · 16:00–19:15 | Fri 08:00-15:00

Representative experience / Issue

International family · Heritage

International divorce in Spain involving digital assets and economic consequences

International jurisdiction, applicable law, matrimonial property regime, digital assets and financial obligations arising from a breakup with international elements.

Materia International divorce
Jurisdiction Spain
Heritage Traditional and digital assets
Procedure International divorce in Spain
01

A divorce before Spanish courts with assets connected to more than one legal system

RRYP Global intervened in an international divorce proceeding in Spain in which the asset dimension included digital assets.

The analysis required separating legally different issues: jurisdiction of the Spanish courts, law applicable to divorce, marital property regime and possible economic consequences of the breakup.

02

Divorce, assets and financial support do not constitute a single legal issue.

The same family conflict may be subject to different regulatory instruments.

The competent court to dissolve the marriage, the law governing divorce, the property relations between the spouses, and subsequent financial obligations must be analyzed separately.

03

An international divorce can be distributed across several regulatory layers

Brussels II ter

Jurisdiction for divorce

Regulation (EU) 2019/1111 contains the European forums for international judicial jurisdiction in matters of divorce, legal separation and annulment of marriage.

Rome III

Law applicable to divorce

Regulation (EU) 1259/2010 determines the law applicable to divorce and legal separation in the participating Member States and has universal application.

Regulation 2016 / 1103

Marital property regime

Where applicable, it regulates jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition and enforcement in matters of matrimonial property regimes.

Its application also requires checking its territorial and transitional rules.

Regulation 4 / 2009

Alimony obligations

Maintenance obligations arising from family relationships, kinship, marriage or affinity have a specific European regime.

The place where the marriage was celebrated does not in itself determine where the divorce can be processed

Brussels II ter primarily uses criteria linked to habitual residence and, in certain cases, to the nationality of the spouses.

Article 3 of this law considers, among other forums, the habitual residence of the spouses, their last common habitual residence when one still resides there, the habitual residence of the defendant, and certain cases based on the habitual residence of the plaintiff.

Consequently, neither the foreign nationality of a spouse nor the celebration of the marriage outside of Spain excludes, in themselves, the possibility that the Spanish courts may be competent.

Celebration of marriage and international judicial jurisdiction are distinct legal connections.

05

The fact that the divorce is processed in Spain does not mean that all its issues are automatically governed by Spanish law.

Judicial jurisdiction and applicable law are distinct questions of Private International Law.

Rome III allows, within the limits of the Regulation, a choice of law by the spouses.

In the absence of a choice, its article 8 establishes successive connections: common habitual residence when the lawsuit is filed; under certain conditions, the last common habitual residence; common nationality; and, subsidiarily, the law of the forum.

A Spanish court may be competent and yet have to apply foreign law to a matter covered by a conflict-of-laws rule.

06

Dissolving a marriage and determining the property regime are different legal operations

The divorce decree does not necessarily follow the same rules that determine the property relations between the spouses.

Regulation (EU) 2016/1103 governs, within its scope, property relations arising from marriage and its dissolution, including issues relating to the classification of assets, powers over property and liquidation of the matrimonial property regime.

Its application should not be taken for granted. The Regulation operates within the framework of enhanced cooperation and contains specific transitional rules. In particular, its provisions on applicable law have time limitations regarding marriages celebrated or choices of law made before 29 January 2019.

In an international marriage, identifying assets is only part of the problem. First, it's necessary to determine which legal regime governs those property relationships.

07

Digital assets do not constitute a separate marital property regime

Technology changes the form of the asset. It does not eliminate fundamental equity questions.

Existence and ownership

What existing assets already exist, and who is responsible for them?

The relationship between technical control and legal ownership must be examined according to the nature of the asset and the applicable asset regime.

Qualification

What treatment does it receive within the marital estate?

The answer does not come from an autonomous rule on “crypto”, but from the law that governs property relations between spouses.

Valuation

What economic value does it represent?

Assets with high volatility or fluctuating liquidity pose different problems than those of a stable or easily realizable asset.

Economic capacity

Equity, liquidity, and income are not equivalent.

The asset's net worth, its availability, its ability to generate returns, and the income actually received are different magnitudes.

08

What is compensatory alimony and when can it exist?

When Spanish law is applicable, the pension under Article 97 of the Civil Code does not automatically arise because one spouse has more assets or income than the other.

Their budget is an economic imbalance caused by separation or divorce that places one of the spouses in a worse economic position compared to that maintained during the marriage.

Compensatory alimony is not a general mechanism for equalizing assets, salaries, or pensions.

The Supreme Court's jurisprudence emphasizes this distinction. At the same time, the subsequent financial situation may be relevant in assessing whether the imbalance persists and to what extent.

01

Agreements reached by the spouses.

02

Age and health status.

03

Professional qualifications and chances of accessing employment.

04

Past and future dedication to family.

05

Collaboration in the professional or business activities of the other spouse.

06

Duration of marriage and conjugal cohabitation.

07

Potential loss of pension rights.

08

Assets, financial resources and needs of both spouses.

09

How is compensatory alimony calculated?

There is no legal formula that allows you to obtain it by applying a fixed percentage to your income or assets.

First, it must be determined whether a legally relevant imbalance exists. The circumstances outlined in Article 97 then serve to assess the benefit and its duration.

The compensation can be structured as a temporary pension, an indefinite pension, or a lump sum payment.

When a limited duration is established, case law requires that there be a sufficiently well-founded expectation that the imbalance can be overcome. A purely abstract possibility of improving the economic situation is not enough.

TS · ECLI:ES:TS:2024:6107

Economic imbalance

The Supreme Court reiterates that the compensatory pension does not constitute a system of balance between assets or between the income of the spouses.

TS · ECLI:ES:TS:2024:6155

Heritage and persistence of imbalance

The subsequent allocation of assets may be relevant to assess whether the imbalance has decreased or disappeared, without this turning the compensatory action into a liquidation of assets.

10

How is child support determined?

Nor is there in Spain a single legal percentage of salary that automatically produces a certain pension.

The Civil Code is based on a principle of proportionality between the economic means of the person who must provide food and the needs of the person who receives it.

Needs

Children's expenses

The benefit must meet the needs covered by the legal concept of food.

Resources

Capacity of both parents

The proportionality test considers the resources and economic capabilities of both parents.

Coexistence

Family organization

The cohabitation arrangements and the length of stay may affect the distribution of the financial contribution.

Housing

Housing component

The need for housing is part of the legal concept of food and may be relevant to its quantification.

Content

More than food

Article 142 includes sustenance, housing, clothing, medical assistance and education under the legally established terms.

CGPJ

Guide tables

The tables of the General Council of the Judiciary are a guiding tool and do not replace the legal and economic assessment of the specific case.

Spanish law

The General Council of the Judiciary (CGPJ) itself currently indicates that its alimony calculation tool is undergoing review and updating.

The classification of a financial benefit is also important in Private International Law

In an international conflict, it is not enough to use the name given to a benefit under national law.

Regulation (EC) 4/2009 governs maintenance obligations arising from family relationships, kinship, marriage, or affinity. Regulation 2016/1103, however, excludes maintenance obligations from its scope relating to matrimonial property regimes.

Therefore, an economic allocation linked to the breakup may require determining beforehand what its legal function is before deciding which European instrument is applicable.

Matrimonial property regime and maintenance obligation are distinct categories within the European system.

12

Assets, imbalance, and alimony are subject to different legal judgments.

Supreme Court · November 28, 2024

compensatory pension

The First Chamber reiterates that compensatory damages do not aim to equalize assets or income. Their purpose is to correct the economic imbalance caused by the separation.

Supreme Court · December 11, 2024

Food proportions

The Court describes the proportionality test as a balancing of the income of both parents and the needs of the children, according to their respective economic capacity.

Legal management of an international divorce with a complex patrimonial dimension

RRYP Global jointly analyzed the international dimension of the breakup, its economic consequences and the asset structure relevant to the proceedings in Spain.

The intervention included the legal study of the matter and the procedural articulation of the divorce proceedings before the Spanish courts.

Legal representation

Mar Gamez

Managing Partner · Legal Department
Lawyer registered no. 137007 ICAM

In international family law, the economic dimension of the breakup must be integrated with judicial jurisdiction, applicable law and property regime.

Mar Gámez carries out academic activity in Comparative Law at Loyola University and directs international private matters at RRYP Global connected with different legal systems and patrimonial structures.

View professional profile →

15 / International family wealth

The heritage can be digital. The legal issue remains one of heritage and international scope.

Crypto assets, digital accounts, or other forms of technologically complex wealth do not eliminate the traditional questions: ownership, legal status, valuation, liquidity, and economic capacity.

When the marital relationship also has connections with different countries, these issues must be integrated into the applicable Private International Law system.

+

International divorce, assets and economic consequences

RRYP Global intervenes in family disputes with international elements when the breakup affects personal or property relationships connected with more than one legal system.

These matters may require integrating Private International Law, matrimonial property regime, alimony obligations, foreign law and patrimonial analysis.

See International Family practice →

Does your divorce involve multiple jurisdictions, complex assets, or significant financial consequences?

In the first legal meeting we analyzed the international connections of the marriage, the economic issues raised, the asset structure and the available documentation.

The first objective is to identify which issues can be resolved in Spain and what legal regime should be applied to each of them.

Acceptance of a new matter is subject to availability, verification of conflicts of interest, and prior definition of the scope of intervention.